Under Contract
Acreage: 565
Status: Under Contract
Whale Cay is a 565-acre private island in the Berry Islands, 30 miles north of Nassau, with a 4,000-foot private runway, the historic Marion Carstairs estate, a 2.5-mile natural waterway, and miles of white-sand beaches along the Tongue of the Ocean.
Freehold
Private Island
Partially Developed
Inquire

Whale Cay

Whale Cay is a private island in the Berry Islands, 565 acres of green scrub, stone and white sand set between the shallow Bahama Banks and the deep water of the Tongue of the Ocean. It lies about 30 miles north of Nassau and close to Florida, in an island chain long prized by fishing and boating enthusiasts, and it is one of the largest private islands in the northern Bahamas to come to market whole.

What sets Whale Cay apart is how much is already here. A 4,000-foot private airstrip runs down its spine, a historic estate built across four decades by Marion Carstairs stands above its eastern shore, and a 2.5-mile natural waterway cuts along the northern side with the makings of a marina. Few islands of this scale, this close to Nassau, are offered entire.

The Island

Whale Cay runs long and low, curving through turquoise water with a different shore on every side. Leeward bays hold crescents of white sand over shallow, glassy flats, while the windward coast rises to rocky headlands and ironshore paths above deeper blue water. Inland, paved roads and sandy tracks cross open scrub and mature island vegetation, linking the airstrip, the estate and the beaches into a single private domain of 565 acres.

The Airstrip and Access

The island is reached by boat, by seaplane, or by air: its 4,000-foot private airstrip is the longest private runway currently available in the Bahamas, able to take owners and guests straight onto the island. By sea, Chub Cay lies 6.5 miles west and serves as the port of entry, with customs, marina facilities, restaurants and supplies, and Nassau is about 30 miles south with its international airport and full services.

View Brochure

Whale Cay brochure

Whale Cay in one document — photos, island facts, and regional background.

The Historic Estate

Between the 1930s and the 1970s, Standard Oil heiress Marion Carstairs built Whale Cay into her own island kingdom, and her buildings still define it. The two-storey stone Great House anchors the estate above the shore, joined by a Guest Cottage and a Music Room, a staff dormitory and a museum. A stone chapel stands in its walled grounds nearby, and a white lighthouse keeps watch from the rocky point. The brokerage listing records five bedrooms and six bathrooms across the property, and the island carries its own infrastructure, including generators and water systems.

The Waterway and Marina Potential

Along the northern side of the island runs a natural waterway 2.5 miles long, about 25 feet wide and 1.5 to 4 feet deep. In its sheltered line is the clear opportunity to dredge a marina basin inside the island itself, giving a future owner protected berthing at the heart of the property rather than on an exposed coast, a rare advantage in the Berry Islands.

The Opportunity

Whale Cay is presented by its brokers as a holding for exclusive residential development or a luxury resort, and the raw material is all in place: 565 acres in one ownership, an airstrip no other private island on the market can match, a waterway ready to become a marina, and a ready-made historic estate at its centre. It can equally remain what Carstairs made it, a private island kingdom of unusual scale and story, 30 miles from Nassau and a world apart.

Read More

Featured Lifestyles: