Disclaimer: Images of homes are artist renderings and not photographs of the actual build.
The Carolina Cays (formerly the Baum Islands) represents a rare offering of 14 private islands located in the Roanoke Sound of the Outer Banks. Spanning a collective 240 acres with approximately 3 miles of shoreline, this assemblage constitutes the last remaining deep-waterfront land in the Manteo and Nags Head region. Properties are available as individual 10-acre private island parcels or as a complete portfolio, offering a legacy investment opportunity in a market typically dominated by multi-generational holdings.
Property Details
These islands are pristine, non-developed parcels that are delivered build-ready. Comprehensive engineering has been completed, with permits available for the installation of wells, septic systems, and deep-water docks. The land features elevations reaching up to 12 feet above sea level, placing the islands within the favorable AE flood zone, a critical advantage for insurance and development feasibility.
Land and Water
The landscape is defined by native vegetation, including year-round oak and cedar trees, interspersed with natural canals, ponds, marshes, and wetlands. The surrounding deep waters support a rich marine ecosystem, offering immediate access for fishing, crabbing, oystering, and shrimping. The area is a recognized destination for birdwatching, home to ospreys and hundreds of other species.
Access and Utilities
Logistics are seamless, with the islands located just minutes from the public boat launch at the Virginia Dare Bridge. Marinas, docks, and dining options in Manteo are within a short boat ride. The properties benefit from the North Atlantic Aquifer for water resources. Security and safety are enhanced by the regular presence of the U.S. Coast Guard in the surrounding waterways.
Lifestyle and Value
This offering allows for the creation of a private family compound, a conservation sanctuary, or a short-term rental destination in one of North Carolina’s most sought-after coastal corridors. Historical provenance adds to the allure, as the islands were once part of a fishing village associated with the "Lost Colony" era. Ownership conveys a unique blend of historical significance, environmental preservation, and developmental readiness.
